From: rob-7704@austin.rr.com (Rob Borowicz)
Subject: Re: Not "Who Are You"... Who Were They?
Received on Mon Feb 8 12:14:07 2010.
I totally agree Scott,
I was watching with my young (16) son and I told him "these guys had
some of the best music ever when I was younger". I proceeded to tell
him about John and Keth and all and his response was "is that the
original drummers kit?" And as he was asking this Zak was doing a
pathetic Keith Moon on Won't Get Fooled aAgain, and sadly I said " no
so that ain't Keith Moon's drums and not even close to what the real guy
could/would do".
-Bob
Scott Perschke wrote:
>
>
> I watched with extreme sadness as the remaining parts of the Who ran
> through the medley last night.
>
> By "parts", I'm not referring to the remaining members - I'm talking
> about the parts OF the remaining members. Part of Daltrey's voice,
> Part of Townshend's guitar playing, the smallest conceivable fraction
> left of what once was.
>
> Absent without leave were the ghosts of Keith Moon and John
> Entwhistle. Were they alive, they would no doubt have realized how bad
> they sounded, and how horrible they looked, and flatly refused to be
> seen or heard in public.
>
> At times during the "performance", Roger started to look, and worse,
> sound like Randy Newman doing a bad Roger Daltrey impression, and Pete
> looked like Frank Perdue or Ed Koch.
>
> Whatever happened to dignity? And "who" will "sell out" for 12 minutes
> of humiliation next year?
>
> Loudon Wainwright said it best (at the writing of the song, George
> Harrison was still alive)..
>
> "Paul and George and Ringo, just a fraction of the Fab Four
> Some still survive from Dave Clark's Five
> Washed up on the Mersey shore.
> Gerry has a pacemaker, that hermit's name is Herman
> That old man's Manfred Mann, and the Animals merely vermin.
>
> .... Rock and roll will never die, neither can her heros
> Just pick a figure with three digits, then tack on about six zeros.
> Here's what gives, Elvis lives,
> What is, in fact, is not.
>
>
>